بسم الله الرحمن الرحيمSeries of Questions Addressed to Scholar Sheikh Ata Bin Khalil Abu Al-RashtahAmeer of Hizb ut Tahrir through his Fiqhi Facebook PageAnswer to the Question Discretionary Penalty (At-Ta’zir): Its Details and Rulings Question Assalamu alaikum, bless you our Sheikh and Ameer and may we blessed with you, the Answer had the following sentence: “As it has legalized discretionary penalty and showed the details of its rulings and its…

May Allah grant you His forgiveness and good health, I have two questions, the first one: It is known that Omar Ibn Al-Khattab (ra) kept the land of Iraq and refused to distribute it to the fighters, the question is: Is this an Ijtihad of Omar Ibn Al-khattab (ra) which others may hold a different Shariah opinion, or is it a consensus of the companions which is prohibited to differ…

What is taking place in Libya is interesting, at a time when military action is increasing, negotiations are under way in France, Algeria, Morocco and Libya itself, what is the explanation of this? Can we say that what is taking place of these two extremes, military actions and negotiations, is the result of a European American conflict in Libya? Is a military intervention through a Security Council resolution expected as…

Can you please explain why the Prophet (saw) gave exception to the Arab Polytheists from the Kuffar of Yemen to remain in their religion? Can we consider this exception regarding the Arab Polytheists a restriction to what is general as what is mentioned in the book, The Islamic State, (Arabic version, 7th edition, page 144; English version, page 139): "These people will be left alone and there is no interference…